ECCC-Report TR21-167https://eccc.weizmann.ac.il/report/2021/167Comments and Revisions published for TR21-167en-usSat, 24 Sep 2022 02:29:47 +0300
Revision 1
| Post-Quantum Zero Knowledge, Revisited (or: How to Do Quantum Rewinding Undetectably) |
Alex Lombardi,
Fermi Ma,
Nicholas Spooner
https://eccc.weizmann.ac.il/report/2021/167#revision1When do classical zero-knowledge protocols remain secure against quantum attacks? In this work, we develop the techniques, tools, and abstractions necessary to answer this question for foundational protocols:
1) We prove that the Goldreich-Micali-Wigderson protocol for graph non-isomorphism and the Feige-Shamir protocol for NP remain zero-knowledge against quantum adversaries. At the heart of our proof is a new quantum rewinding technique that enables extracting information from multiple invocations of a quantum adversary without disturbing its state.
2) We prove that the Goldreich-Kahan protocol for NP is post-quantum zero knowledge using a simulator that can be seen as a natural quantum extension of the classical simulator.
Our results achieve negligible simulation error, appearing to contradict a recent impossibility result due to Chia-Chung-Liu-Yamakawa (FOCS 2021). This brings us to our final contribution:
3) We introduce coherent-runtime expected quantum polynomial time, a simulation notion that (1) precisely captures all of our zero-knowledge simulators, (2) cannot break any polynomial hardness assumptions, (3) implies strict polynomial-time epsilon-simulation and (4) is not subject to the CCLY impossibility. In light of our positive results and the CCLY negative results, we propose coherent-runtime simulation to be the appropriate quantum analogue of classical expected polynomial-time simulation.Sat, 24 Sep 2022 02:29:47 +0300https://eccc.weizmann.ac.il/report/2021/167#revision1
Paper TR21-167
| Post-Quantum Zero Knowledge, Revisited (or: How to Do Quantum Rewinding Undetectably) |
Alex Lombardi,
Fermi Ma,
Nicholas Spooner
https://eccc.weizmann.ac.il/report/2021/167A major difficulty in quantum rewinding is the fact that measurement is destructive: extracting information from a quantum state irreversibly changes it. This is especially problematic in the context of zero-knowledge simulation, where preserving the adversary's state is essential.
In this work, we develop new techniques for quantum rewinding in the context of extraction and zero-knowledge simulation:
1. We show how to extract information from a quantum adversary by rewinding it without disturbing its internal state. We use this technique to prove that important interactive protocols, such as the Goldreich-Micali-Wigderson protocol for graph non-isomorphism and the Feige-Shamir protocol for NP, are zero-knowledge against quantum adversaries.
2. We prove that the Goldreich-Kahan protocol for NP is post-quantum zero knowledge using a simulator that can be seen as a natural quantum extension of the classical simulator.
Our results achieve (constant-round) black-box zero-knowledge with negligible simulation error, appearing to contradict a recent impossibility result due to Chia-Chung-Liu-Yamakawa (FOCS 2021). This brings us to our final contribution:
3. We introduce coherent-runtime expected quantum polynomial time, a computational model that (a) captures all of our zero-knowledge simulators, (b) cannot break any polynomial hardness assumptions, and (c) is not subject to the CCLY impossibility. In light of our positive results and the CCLY negative results, we propose coherent-runtime simulation to be the right quantum analogue of classical expected polynomial-time simulation.Tue, 23 Nov 2021 13:09:07 +0200https://eccc.weizmann.ac.il/report/2021/167