Revision #1 Authors: Stasys Jukna, Hannes Seiwert

Accepted on: 30th May 2018 18:20

Downloads: 377

Keywords:

Many dynamic programming algorithms for discrete 0-1 optimizationproblems are ``pure'' in that their recursion equations only use min/max and addition operations, and do not depend on actual input weights. The well-known greedy algorithm of Kruskal solves the minimum weight spanning tree problem on $n$-vertex graphs using only $O(n^2\log n)$ operations. We prove that any pure DP algorithm for this problem must perform $2^{\Omega(\sqrt{n})}$ operations. Since the greedy algorithm can also badly fail on some optimization problems, easily solvable by pure DP algorithms, our result shows that the computational powers of these two types of algorithms are incomparable.

The first structural claim of the Forest lemma (that the sets of vertices in the connected components of all forests from one side must be the same) in the previous version is just wrong. We now use entirely different arguments to prove a slightly weaker version of the numerical claim of the Forest lemma. The resulting lower bound is weaker, but still exponential.

TR18-049 Authors: Stasys Jukna, Hannes Seiwert

Publication: 14th March 2018 19:21

Downloads: 1287

Keywords:

Many dynamic programming algorithms are ``pure'' in that they only use min or max and addition operations in their recursion equations. The well known greedy algorithm of Kruskal solves the minimum weight spanning tree problem on $n$-vertex graphs using only $O(n^2\log n)$ operations. We prove that any pure DP algorithm for this problem must perform $2^{\Omega(n)}$ operations. Since the greedy algorithm can also badly fail on some optimization problems, easily solvable by pure DP algorithms, our result shows that the computational powers of these two types of algorithms are incomparable.